The writer’s necessary (1)

What does it take to be a writer? Many writers would say “courage.”  But what do we mean when we say courage in this context?  Courage, and other conditions of being a writer, will be the topic of this new series.

Look at the question again.  What does it take to be a writer?  It’s a question about being, about identity, so the answers will concern the psychological or existential aspects of the potential writer.  It’s not a question about doing.  If you’re interested in doing writing, that’s easy.  You need to watch your bullets and numbered lists and consult Copyblogger tout de suite.


What many writers mean by courage is the courage to write what one wants to write, instead of what one feels one ought to write.  It’s the courage to give up the ought and go with the want.  And this is THE hard thing.  Nothing harder, in fact.  In writing, and in all of life.

There’s a story I heard recently about the comic writer, David Sedaris, which illustrates the point. (1)

Sedaris was talking to an audience about an incident that had happened when he was a young schoolboy.  One day, his English teacher had asked the class to nominate the best song on the top 40.  Sedaris, encouraged by a question which surely had “no right answer” — or, as he says, “so he thought” — stuck up his hand and nominated his song.  For the young Sedaris, this song was not only the best song in the top 40, but “possibly the best song ever.”

It was a song, he says, that

satisfied me on every level.

Sedaris described what happened after he put up his hand:

… what I remember is not so much my recommendation, but the silence that followed it … an absence of agreement I can only describe as deafening.

And suddenly, the song he had played over and over again, the song that had satisfied him on every level turned to ashes.

… if nobody else liked it, I guessed I didn’t either.  That evening, alone in my room, I found that I was too ashamed to listen to my record, to even look at it …

What’s great about Sedaris’s story is that it’s every person’s story.  We’ve all been there, all heard the deafening sound of approval being withdrawn.

And yet this is the terrain one must tread in being a writer.

The fundamental task of being a writer is to give up the consciousness of that heavy-breathing monster the audience, that thing with each eyeball an ought.  To give up the wanting to please, to give up, yes … the seduction.  And to do so neverendingly, over and over again, sentence by sentence.

This is courage, and this is what’s required in being a writer.

But perhaps you’re asking what’s left?  If I give up my wanting to please, my seductiveness, what will I be doing when I’m writing?

Roberto Rossellini, a great writer in the medium of film, supplies an answer.  As his artistry evolved and he found the courage to go beyond seduction he discovered the refinements of offering instead.


Next time, another condition of being a writer: getting straight about ambiguity.


1. As quoted in Insights and Distinctions: Landmark Essays by Nancy Zapolski and Joe DiMaggio

Images: David Sedaris, still doing time for his classroom gaffe, courtesy of The Guardian (top); image from Rome, Open City by Roberto Rossellini, courtesy of Supanet (bottom)


6 thoughts on “The writer’s necessary (1)

  1. In teaching writing for a good many years, I would agree fully with you here, that writing takes individuation and courage at the highest levels–especially when faced with a teacher’s/publisher’s/editorial board’s/ judgment.

    Sometimes, in uploading a piece for my blog, I wonder what people will think about my content/expression/lack thereof and then catch myself: why do I care?

    I’d be lying if I said I didn’t care. And I’m 59 yrs. old.

    (How’s that for bravery?)


  2. Ah, D, no deafening sound of approval being withdrawn from this quarter. Nina Simone! The queen. Getting out old battered “Released” CD to listen to “I’ve got life” as we speak. And what about “Do I move you”?? When she does that little verbal shimmy thing …


Your comment will be an adornment to this blog ...

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s