Australia vs US: A comment to Waleed Aly on the question of mythology (For Aussie readers)

Australian flag on blue sky

Waleed Aly in today’s Age speculates on Australia’s defensiveness about our past, particularly the fact of Indigenous dispossession through British colonisation. He correctly points to this generating a nation that is thin-skinned, anxious, full of zealously patrolled false pride, and liable to react to the slightest criticism.

He contrasts our defensiveness and immaturity with the US, where the mistakes and failures of the past are “not fatal to its identity.”

He says this:

The US is built on the idea of constant progress through individual liberty. It’s a nation that is never finished, never perfect, but always being perfected. Its historical scars are therefore not fatal to its identity. Indeed, they are essential because they allow Americans to tell a story of their own perfectibility. In these hands, slavery is not simply a stain, but a symbol of how far they’ve come. So, in the process of acknowledging slavery, the US is celebrated, not condemned.

We’re not like that. We struggle with our history because once we admit it, we have nowhere to go with it; no way of rehabilitating our pride; no way of understanding ourselves. As a nation, we lack a national mythology that can cope with our shortcomings. That transforms our historical scars into fatal psychological wounds, leaving us with a bizarre need to insist everything was – and is – as good as it gets.

It’s interesting material, and there’s something I want to tweak in his account. It’s not quite right to say or imply that having a national mythology would allow us to look at our shortcomings. That’s putting the cart before the horse.

A national mythology, the kind that would transform our nation, is not something that can exist before the fact. It’s something that must emerge from the enquiry into the past and its mistakes. The enquiry into the past, the willingness to look, is what generates the possibility of the new.

First, there’s the willingness, the humility, the act of grace involved in not hiding, in not-knowing. Then, from it, out of it, arises the possibility of transformation, the new, the re-born identity.

Unless and until Australia is willing to look into the crypt, there can be no powerful national mythology, no transformation.

As it is for the country, so it is for the individual. Each individual of any country. First, there’s the willingness to look, then there’s the possibility of transformation. Always that order. Always that pre-requisite.


Here is the full article: Why Australia lies to itself about its Indigenous history



4 thoughts on “Australia vs US: A comment to Waleed Aly on the question of mythology (For Aussie readers)

    • I get your point. Two things for me in response. 1. Myth or mythology is not the best word here. Identity or wholeness or “story with which one integrates the good and the bad, the mistakes and the felicities” is better. 2. Transformation, identity-creating, is an ongoing process. Yesterday’s transformation is today’s blind spot. Identities, integrating stories, wear out their usefulness and power. The necessity of going into the fire again is never far off. The US is maybe in the fire right now.

      Liked by 2 people

  1. **First, there’s the willingness to look, then there’s the possibility of transformation. Always that order. ***

    We are hopefully, in transformation. I love America, but not what I am seeing at the present moment….So embarrassing.

    But I believe in transformation and renewal and new beginnings.

    I def. do not like what Waleed Aly has to say about Austarlia….as if there is no hope, not chance to change.

    Thank God he’s not your Prime Minister.

    xxx kiss from MN.


Your comment will be an adornment to this blog ...

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s